Underpaid Insurance Claim? What to Do Next

If your insurance claim payout feels too low, you might be dealing with an underpaid claim. This happens when insurers pay less than what your policy promises, leaving you to cover repair costs or medical bills. Here’s how to address it:

• Understand Why Claims Are Underpaid: Common reasons include software undervaluing damages, incomplete inspections, depreciation deductions, or outdated repair costs.

• Spot the Signs: Look for repair cost gaps, ignored damages, or slow claim processing.

• Check Your Policy: Review your coverage details, limits, and valuation methods (Replacement Cost vs. Actual Cash Value).

• Gather Evidence: Take photos, get contractor estimates, and save all communication with your insurer.

• Negotiate: Write a clear appeal letter, present evidence, and work with adjusters professionally.

• Get Help: Consider hiring a public adjuster or insurance lawyer for complex cases.

Quick Tip: Strong documentation and persistence are key to securing a fair settlement. If needed, escalate unresolved issues to your state’s insurance commissioner.

Check Your Policy and Settlement Details

Read Your Policy Terms

Take a close look at your policy's declaration page (often called the "dec" page). This section outlines key details like the types of coverage you have, the limits for each, property information, deductibles, and any additional riders or endorsements. Some coverage limits might be tied to a percentage of your dwelling coverage. For instance, coverage for personal belongings, other structures, or loss of use may be calculated based on a fixed percentage. Go through your policy thoroughly to understand these specifics.

Check Your Settlement Amount

Compare the settlement amount you’ve received to the actual costs of repairs and pay attention to the valuation method used. If your policy includes Replacement Cost Coverage, it reimburses you for the full cost to replace items without factoring in depreciation. On the other hand, Actual Cash Value coverage deducts depreciation, which could lead to a smaller payout. Understanding which method applies is crucial in evaluating if your claim has been settled fairly.

Find Payment Gaps

Look for any gaps in your settlement that could leave you under-covered. These might include:

• Coverage Limits: Your policy might not cover enough, especially for high-value items or specific situations.

• Building Costs: If the construction costs used by the insurer are outdated, you may need updated contractor estimates.

• Code Requirements: If your policy doesn’t include ordinance coverage, you may have to request coverage for building code upgrades.

• Additional Expenses: Costs like debris removal might be excluded and could lower your overall payout.

• Special Items: Coverage for valuable items may be limited, signaling a need for separate endorsements.

Once you’ve identified these gaps, gather strong evidence to support a revised claim.

Denied or Underpaid Insurance Claim: What You Need to Know

Build Your Case with Evidence

After reviewing your policy and settlement details, gather detailed documentation of all damage and repair costs to strengthen your claim.

Take Photos and Videos

Create a clear visual record that includes:

• Damage to structures and materials, along with evidence of the cause.

• Hidden problems, supported by tools like moisture readings.

• Before-and-after comparisons, if available.

• Notes on the date, location, and specific damage for each photo.

Make sure to label all images with relevant details so adjusters can easily understand the extent of the damage.

Get Multiple Repair Quotes

Getting quotes from several contractors could reduce costs by 10-15%. When requesting quotes:

• Ask for detailed assessments of the damage.

• Compare how different contractors plan to handle the repairs.

• Ensure the quotes are recent, itemized, and easy to understand.

• Note any cost differences between vendors.

According to a J.D. Power survey, 34% of policyholders who used insurance company-recommended vendors reported higher-than-expected costs. Independent quotes can help ensure pricing is fair.

Save All Insurance Communications

In addition to visual evidence and repair estimates, keep a record of every interaction with your insurer. Organize these chronologically:

• Emails and letters.

• Details of phone calls (date, time, and representative's name).

• Claim forms and reports.

• Written confirmations of verbal discussions.

It’s a good idea to follow up verbal conversations with email summaries to maintain a clear documentation trail. Keeping everything organized will help you make a strong case for any additional payments.

Talk to Your Insurance Company

Once you’ve gathered thorough documentation, it’s time to approach your insurance company and challenge the payout.

Write Your Appeal

Start by drafting a clear, fact-driven appeal letter for your insurer. Stick to the details and explain why the settlement doesn’t cover your losses.

Make sure to include:

• Claim number and date of loss

• The amount you believe was underpaid

• Relevant sections of your policy that support your case

• A detailed breakdown of repair costs

• All supporting documents

Show Your Evidence

Organize your evidence carefully to strengthen your case during the review process.

| <strong>Type of Evidence</strong> | <strong>What to Include</strong> |
| --- | --- |
| <strong>Visual Documentation</strong> | Photos, videos, moisture readings |
| <strong>Cost Documentation</strong> | Contractor estimates, receipts, invoices |
| <strong>Communication Records</strong> | Emails, letters, call logs |
| <strong>Expert Opinions</strong> | Professional assessments, engineer reports

Work with Insurance Adjusters

When negotiating with insurance adjusters, stay professional but firm. Adjusters work for the insurance company, so it’s important to advocate for your claim effectively.

Here are some key tactics:

• Stay calm, stick to the facts, and keep a record of every interaction.

• Ask for detailed explanations of how they calculated the settlement.

• Use your evidence to back up counter-offers.

• Follow up regularly, but always remain polite and professional.

• If necessary, request a review by a supervisor.

If negotiations stall, think about reaching out to a public adjuster or attorney for assistance. Keep in mind that initial settlement offers are often lower than the actual repair costs, so strong negotiation is essential to securing fair compensation.

Get Expert Help

If your claim has been underpaid, getting professional assistance can help you secure a better settlement. These experts step in when communication with your insurer doesn't yield the desired results.

Hire a Public Adjuster

Public adjusters work exclusively for you, helping to negotiate higher settlements and navigate complicated claims. They’re especially helpful for large, complex, or underpaid claims.

| When to Hire | Benefits | Typical Costs |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Large or Complex Claims | Guidance on your policy, skilled negotiation | Up to 10% of settlement |
| Denied or Underpaid Claims | Detailed documentation and advocacy | Contingency fee applies |
| Multiple Damage Types | Thorough evaluation and reporting | State-regulated percentage

After major disasters, public adjusters often help policyholders achieve better settlements by providing detailed documentation and presenting claims effectively.

Work with an Insurance Lawyer

If your insurer isn’t negotiating fairly or is acting in bad faith, an insurance lawyer can be a game-changer. Legal help is especially important in situations like:

• Your insurer refuses to negotiate reasonably

• Evidence of bad faith practices

• High-value claims

• Cases requiring expert testimony

• Long delays in settlement

Most insurance lawyers work on a contingency fee basis, meaning they only get paid if you win.

Quality Restoration NW LLC: Insurance Claim Support

In addition to public adjusters and legal help, restoration firms like Quality Restoration NW LLC play a key role in supporting your insurance claim. They provide essential on-site documentation to back up your case. Their services include:

• Detailed damage assessments with photos and reports

• Professional documentation to assist your adjuster

• Direct communication with your insurer

• Expert testimony on repair costs

• Help with supplemental claims

With their 24/7 emergency response, they can immediately document damage, which is critical for accurate claim evaluations. Their moisture readings, damage reports, and repair estimates ensure insurers have all the information they need to process claims correctly.

Next Steps

Now that you've presented your case and reached out to your insurer, here's how to work toward a resolution.

Know Your Insurance Rights

Understanding your rights helps you ensure fair treatment from your insurer. They are required to meet state deadlines and handle claims fairly. Keeping detailed records can strengthen your position if any disputes arise.

| <strong>Policyholder Rights</strong> | <strong>Insurer Obligations</strong> |
| --- | --- |
| Timely claim processing | Respond within state-mandated timeframes |
| Fair claim evaluation | Provide clear explanations for decisions |
| Right to appeal | Review additional evidence if provided |
| Professional representation | Allow third-party assistance

Your evidence and expert reports are key to supporting your right to a fair review.

Use Evidence and Experts

The more thorough your documentation, the stronger your case. Include items like:

• Before-and-after photos

• Estimates from independent contractors

• Expert assessments

• Communication records

• Repair receipts

These materials, combined with expert opinions, can significantly strengthen your appeal.

Follow Up Until Resolved

Consistent follow-up is critical. Stay in contact with your adjuster through regular check-ins, written status updates, and detailed communication logs. Track every interaction, including response times.

If your insurer doesn’t respond or delays action, escalate the matter to your state’s insurance commissioner or consider legal assistance. You might also hire a public adjuster to handle the claims process on your behalf - they can help ensure you receive a fair settlement.

Related Blog Posts

• Ultimate Guide to Fire Damage Insurance Claims

• 10 Mistakes to Avoid in Insurance Claims

• How To Avoid Delays in Property Damage Claims

• Top Challenges With Adjusters During Restoration